The framework of government in the Christian Science movement is the conception
of law set forth in the church Manual by Mary Baker Eddy, which provides no forum
of discussion or debate in which her By-Laws might be interpreted and applied.
The
theory often advanced that the final power of control should rest with the body of
church congregants, as is usual in political and social organizations, applies here
in this instance as well, although in a unique and different way.
The congregants
did not originate the By-Laws in Mrs. Eddy’s church Manual. The Manual came from
Mrs. Eddy herself, with whom alone remained all power not granted specifically therein
in writing to someone else or in the printed word.
The three necessary and
distinct departments of government systems throughout the world are the legislative,
the executive, and the judicial departments.
Students of sound political structure
tell us that the consolidation (centralization) of these three naturally and necessarily
distinct departments open the door to tyranny for the status of the institution or
the state.
Successful governments have recognized this and have enjoyed prosperity
as they have maintained the three departments separate and distinct. No clearer example
of this recognized ideal, may be found than in the form of the government for the
United States of America.
The government for the Christian Science movement
presents the same distinctive features that characterize successful forms of government
worldwide and assures its perpetuity.
The legislative element of government
can be found in Mrs. Eddy church Manual, a simple body of "behavioral"
laws that she said can never be changed, made possible only because of the spiritual
insight and foresight of their originator, herself.
The executive element
of government was intended to be found vested in the Christian Science Board of Directors,
consisting of the four director/trustees operating under the 1892 Deed of Trust that
established a "place" of worship located in Boston, Massachusetts.
But
where is the judicial element based upon authority to be found? Authority that has
stood as the guardian of liberty and protection from despotism. Does our Manual have
such a written provision for such a form?
Well, aware as we are of the completeness
of the Christian Science movement, providing as it does for every need and contingency,
we shall not look in vain for this judicial element. It does indeed exist, and is
actively functioning for the well-being of our Cause.
Our revered and honored
Leader was not a lawyer as such, and yet her knowledge of legal rules necessary for
the protection of the movement exceeded the wisdom of erudite men of law schooled
in their profession.
Since she has left us, the entire structure of her Cause
has been subjected to the violence of unprecedented storm, only to outride at last
the hurricanes and rest serene.
Mrs. Eddy perceived clearly what the architects
of our country’s government from their material viewpoint did not see, that there
exists spiritually, as is stated in her own words in Science and Health (p.437),
“The Supreme Court of Spirit, the final arbiter of Truth over error. Before it the
turbulent senses are brought to silence. Justice prevails throughout its hallowed
halls. Confidence and peace pervade its sanctum. Its laws covers the universe and
man."